Oldham Historical Research Group

'THE GREAT WAR',     'THE WAR TO END WAR',     'WORLD WAR 1'
'What passing-bells for these who die as cattle?
- Only the monstrous anger of the guns.'
                                                                                                  
from 'Anthem for Doomed Youth' by Wilfred Owen

CONSCIENTIOUS OBJECTION IN WW1

David Aston

Oldham Tribunal 3 July 1916
Reported Oldham Chronicle 8 July 1916

Several Oldham men appealed to the Oldham Tribunal on Monday afternoon for exemption from service on the ground that they hold a conscientious objection against war and against having connection with the war …

David Aston, of Milford-avenue, Oldham, an electrical meter erector employed by Messrs. Ferranti, Ltd., also a member of the Christadelphian Church, presented his claim for exemption on religious and conscientious grounds.
Councillor Frith asked him if he had any objection to non-combatant service. He replied that he had, because it was a military affair.

Councillor Frith: You are against working on munitions?
- Not necessarily so.
Councillor Frith: For what reason?
- It is not a military affair.
Councillor Frith: But Ferranti's is a controlled firm, and under the Government?
- It doesn't come under the heading of military. It has no military jurisdiction.
Chairman: If at your works you were put on specific war material you would do it?
- Yes.
The appeal was disallowed and Aston accordingly sent to combatant service, although, of course, there is the right to appeal against the decision.

In Aston's case and the following one [John Weeder] the tribunal did not see the consistency of a conscience that objected to non-combatant service and allowed of working on munitions.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Born Dudley, Staffordshire, 12 October 1877
Died Oldham, 28 February 1940

1911 census
5 Windsor Street, Failsworth
With wife Edith, no children
Occ: Electrical armature maker, Electrical meter makers

1939 register
27 Lynton Avenue, Oldham
With wife Edith, no children listed
Occ: Clerk m**chine [?]

Contributed by Dorothy Bintley

Return to :
link to Local CO list

If you can add to our information about any of the local Conscientious Objectors in WW1 we would love to hear from you.
Email

If you have Oldham and District items that we can include on our website, PLEASE visit the information page to find out how you can help.

link to home page
WW1 menu page
WW1 links page